RE: Suggestion for ebXML Knowledge Dissemination

["Paul R. Levine" <plevine@telcordia.com>]

I agree with William.  I also agree with the approach Bob has taken to specify
narrative flows.  This is very much in the flavor of requirements like the
UML-based BP modeling  methodology says should be stated in the first place.

Regards,

Paul
---------------------- Forwarded by Paul R. Levine/Telcordia on 06/28/2000 02:07
PM ---------------------------


Bob Haugen <linkage@interaccess.com> on 06/28/2000 12:33:52 PM

To:   "'William J. Kammerer'" <wkammerer@foresightcorp.com>,
      "'ebXML-BP@lists.oasis-open.org'" <ebXML-BP@lists.oasis-open.org>
cc:    (bcc: Paul R. Levine/Telcordia)
Subject:  RE: Suggestion for ebXML Knowledge Dissemination




I had a several-message discussion of the BP metamodel
in the ebXML-Awareness list with William Kammerer.
I'm sending excerpts to the BP list to see what we can
do about his main criticism, and also copying William
so he can add more (if I excerpted too little) and see
if he thinks any of the suggestions for improvement
will do any good.

If you want to read the whole discussion, go to the
Awareness list archives at:
http://www.xml.org/archives/ebxml-awareness/2000/06/

I think Mr. Kammerer is just what the metamodel document
needs right now: a critical reader.  His main criticism
is that the UML diagrams are unreadable, especially
the first big one:

>Yes, I realize use of UML was "mandated.  But pretty much all the UML
>diagrams give me a headache - perhaps I need to take the UML for Dummies
>class.  And the ebXML Business Process Metamodel on Page 4 of the BP
>First Draft is out of this world;  I would call it spaghetti-code.

I agree with him.  The usual rule of thumb is about 7 elements
in one diagram; this one has more than 30 boxes, lots of
criss-crossed lines, no point of focus, no place to start,
no thread to follow, etc.

Now, all the members of the BP team knew this diagram
was too complicated, but to get our work done, we pretty much
needed one all-inclusive diagram.  However, I think it is time
to figure out how to present the results for ease of reading.

Here is a suggestion:
Break the diagram up into sections, not according to the
current packages, but according to a narrative flow.

For example, maybe:
* A Party plays PartnerRoles in BusinessTransactions.
  BusinessTransactions consist of InformationExchanges which
  exchange BusinessMessages.
* BusinessTransactions may be grouped as StepDefinitions
  in BusinessProcessDefinitions.
* BusinessTransactions may result in BusinessEvents which
   affect BusinessEntitys.
* SomeBusinessEvents are EconomicEvents which transfer
  ownership of EconomicResources.
* BusinessEntities may be Agreements, EconomicResources,
  or EconomicResourceTypes.
* Some Agreements are Contracts.  Contracts make Commitments
   about future EconomicEvents.

I'm not saying this is the correct narrative flow, but I am
proposing narrative flows with storyboard-like visuals
as one alternative that may present the metamodel
more clearly.

William, BP team, what do you think?
(Later, I will summarize the discussion into formal comments
for the BP comments table.)

Regards,
Bob Haugen


=======================================================================
= This is ebxml-bp, the general mailing list for the ebXML            =
= Business Process project team. The owner of this list is            =
= owner-ebxml-bp@oasis-open.org                                       =
=                                                                     =
= To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@lists.oasis-open.org with    =
= the following in the body of the message:                           =
=      unsubscribe ebxml-bp                                           =
= If you are subscribed using a different email address, put the      =
= address you subscribed with at the end of the line; e.g.            =
=      unsubscribe ebxml-bp myname@company.com                        =
=======================================================================




=======================================================================
= This is ebxml-bp, the general mailing list for the ebXML            =
= Business Process project team. The owner of this list is            =
= owner-ebxml-bp@oasis-open.org                                       =
=                                                                     =
= To unsubscribe, send mail to majordomo@lists.oasis-open.org with    =
= the following in the body of the message:                           =
=      unsubscribe ebxml-bp                                           =
= If you are subscribed using a different email address, put the      =
= address you subscribed with at the end of the line; e.g.            =
=      unsubscribe ebxml-bp myname@company.com                        =
=======================================================================