ebxml-architecture message


OASIS Mailing List ArchivesView the OASIS mailing list archive below
or browse/search using MarkMail.

 


Help: OASIS Mailing Lists Help | MarkMail Help
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index]

Subject: RE: Comments on TA doc V1.0


Harald,
	if this is the opinion of the majority, I do not object.
I would only prefer to avoid that the TA document contains description of
UIDs so many times.

/stefano

» -----Original Message-----
» From: Harald Hauschildt [mailto:hha@mosaic-ag.com]
» Sent: 29 January 2001 15:21
» To: 'Stefano POGLIANI'; Petit, John; ebxml-architecture@lists.ebxml.org
» Subject: RE: Comments on TA doc V1.0
»
»
»
» Hi Stefano, hi John, hi List!
» I like to express my point of view to the UID-discussion below...I
» did that earlier during the review cycle...
»
» The whole ebxml idea becomes much more clear at least to the
» (converter-)developers if
» the term UID/GUID would be explicit used within the TA doc.
» To distinguish the concept of ebxml from other concepts (e.g.
» BizTalk), to proof that
» ebxml is not just another standard und to show to the world that we
» have learned from
» the past 20 years of EDI(fact) the term of UID/GUID should be
» descripted within the
» TA doc.
» I agree with Johns comment that "UIDs are going to play a critical
» role in cross schema
» interoperability and semantics" and that the TA doc should covers
» this topic as a bridge between
» the different groups docs.
» I agree also with John that "others would like to see [UID's covered
» by the TA doc] as well as evidenced by the recent flurry of emails
» over the use of UIDs"..........at least me.
»
» Best wishes,
»
» Harald
»
» //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
» /////////////////////
» Dr. Harald Hauschildt		email: hha@mosaic-ag.com
» MOSAIC SOFTWARE AG		Tel: +49-(0)2225-882-425
» Feldstr. 8			Fax: +49-(0)2225-882-201
» D-53340 Meckenheim
» //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
» /////////////////////
»
»
»
» -----Original Message-----
» From:	Stefano POGLIANI [SMTP:stefano.pogliani@sun.com]
» Sent:	Monday, January 29, 2001 12:16 PM
» To:	Petit, John; ebxml-architecture@lists.ebxml.org
» Subject:	RE: Comments on TA doc V1.0
»
» John,
»
»     two words on your comment on my comments:
»
» "...I disagree with Stefano Pogliani's comment to downplay UID
» references in
» the TA doc. The use of UIDs goes across several ebXML groups (CC,
» Registry,
» BP, etc)  and UIDs are going to play a critical role in cross schema
» interoperability and semantics.  As the TA doc should illustrate
» concepts
» that bridge several ebXML groups, UIDs should certainly be covered in
» the TA
» doc. In fact, I would like to see a bit more of an explanation of the
» UID
» mechanism for semantic translation of XML documents. Clearly this is
» something others would like to see as well as evidenced by the recent
» flurry
» of emails over the use of UIDs."
»
» My comments raise from the following:
»   1.. If CC, BP and CPA would require explicitely to use the UIDs,
» then this
» may be an "architectural" thing.
»   In this case I would "move" the explanation of them outside of the
» RegRep
» since, as you note, it is a technology that spans different domains.
» At this
» point, I would make a paragraph somewhere saying that, whenever a
» Unique ID
» is required, then the GUID (or any other mechanism) will be used
» consistently and this same mechanism will be enforced by the RegRep.
»   2.. If other teams do not need to explicitely reference UIDs, then
» it will
» be something inside the RegRep and it will be a technical
» implementation.
» I am not saying to remove any and all of the occurrences of
» UID-related
» sentences. I am trying to say that this would need to be a fair small
» section that does not need to be repeated in too many places.
»
» /Stefano
»   -----Original Message-----
»   From: Petit, John [mailto:jpetit@kpmg.com]
»   Sent: 29 January 2001 01:23
»   To: 'ebxml-architecture@lists.ebxml.org'
»   Subject: Comments on TA doc V1.0
»
»
»   Here are my comments in Word format.
»
»   Cheers, John Petit
»   KPMG Consulting
»   XMLfs Team
»   Office: 970 728 9468
»   Mobile: 312 961 8956
»
»
»  << File: ATT00001.htm >>
»
»



[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index]
Search: Match: Sort by:
Words: | Help

Powered by eList eXpress LLC