RE: Commentson" ebXML specification for the application of XML b ased assembly and contextrules" ver. 1.01

["Miller, Robert (GXS)" <Robert.Miller@gxs.ge.com>]

James and Others,

It would seem to me that comments received outside a formal comment period
should not be ignored, discouraged, or put down, especially when the
docuemnt still has more hoops to jump through before it is approved.  In
such cases, the comments are not 'late' for the last iteration, rather they
are 'early' for the next iteration.  What's more, 'early' comments may offer
the possibility of early response, thereby avoiding more iterations (or even
disapproval). 

In your first paragraph, you make i reasonably clear that you will not pay
attention to the comments.  That is, they will become 'null and void' as
they address a previous version (who cares that the same comments apply to
the new version, since the comments were ignored).

In the second paragraph, you stress that 'we appreciate the efforts these
comments represent'.  Looks to me from the comments in paragraph 1 that
these comments are explicitly not appreciated!

Cheers,
        Bob  

-----Original Message-----
From: James Whittle [mailto:james.whittle@e-centre.org.uk]
Sent: Friday, March 30, 2001 1:29 AM
To: 'Petit, John'; 'ebxml-core@lists.ebxml.org'
Subject: RE: Comments on" ebXML specification for the application of XML
b ased assembly and context rules" ver. 1.01


John and others, I would like to point out that the comment period for these
documents has ended. As the documents are being reviewed by QRT they are
effectively frozen and as a result of QRT's recommendations they may change
significantly. In which case comments made outside the comment period will
become null and void as they will be addressing a previous version.
 
As focal point of the CC editing team I must stress that while we appreciate
the efforts these comments represent we must also ask for at least some
respect for the review processes which are clearly documented at
www.ebxml.org <http://www.ebxml.org> . 
 
Kind regards

James Whittle

E Business standards executive

Tel. No. 44 (0)20 7655 9022

Fax No. 44 (0)20 7681 2278

 

10 Maltravers Street, LONDON, WC2R 3BX.

www Address:  <http://www.e-centre.org.uk/> www.e-centre.org.uk 

e-mail  <mailto:james.whittle@e-centre.org.uk> james.whittle@e-centre.org.uk

 

Best business practice in a digital age.

Disclaimer Notice 

The above information is intended only for the person(s) or entity to which
it is addressed, and may contain confidential or privileged material. Any
use (including retransmission or copying) of this information by person(s)
or entity other than the intended recipient is STRICTLY PROHIBITED. If you
are not the intended recipient of this transmission, please would you
contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. The sender is
not responsible for the completeness or accuracy of this communication as it
has been transmitted over a public network. Any views or opinions are solely
those of the author, and do not necessarily represent those of e centreUK.
All third party rights are duly acknowledged. e centreUK is the trade name
of the Association for Standards and Practices in Electronic Trade - EAN UK
Limited, and is registered in the United Kingdom (Registration Number
1256140). 

© 2000 All Rights Reserved

-----Original Message-----
From: Petit, John [mailto:jpetit@kpmg.com]
Sent: 30 March 2001 04:42
To: 'ebxml-core@lists.ebxml.org'
Subject: Comments on" ebXML specification for the application of XML based
assembly and context rules" ver. 1.01


Lines 578 - 580: It is not defined how these two processors working with
different syntax mappings could figure out in the first place that these two
schemas had anything to do with each other. What is the discovery process?
 
Lines 581 - 583: Since this assembled document is apparently a transitory
one (not persisted), then how will this "map" be generated? Is this an
automated process? If so, it should be spelled out more clearly in the spec.
 
Cheers, John Petit 
Manager, KPMG 
XMLfs 
Office: 970 728 9468 
Mobile: 312 961 8956 
 


------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this elist send a message with the single word
"unsubscribe" in the body to: ebxml-core-request@lists.ebxml.org