Re: [ebxml-mktg-sc] For Friday: Revised Messaging Assessment WP attached

[Alan Kotok <akotok@disa.org>]

David, et al.

Point of clarification:  AS1 applies to EDI transactions sent over SMTP and 
AS2 covers EDI transactions sent over HTTP.  AS2 does not necessarily 
supercede AS1; they are supposed to be peers.  In practice, few if any 
organizations use AS1, while AS2 has garnered something of a following.

Alan Kotok
Editor, < E-Business*Standards*Today />
http://www.disa.org/dailywire/
Data Interchange Standards Association
akotok@disa.org
+1 703-518-4174



At 12:32 AM 5/1/03 -0400, David RR Webber - XML ebusiness wrote:
>Monica,
>
>OK - that makes sense.  We could mention them in the Business section,
>and note they were not included because of industry sector, I like that.
>We could also put AS1 in there, since AS2 supercedes it, and then
>we could probably add some others like FIX and SWIFT that are
>industry specific too.
>
>Any others, Alan / Mark, or is that representative enough?
>
>Also Monica - nice set of edits - most look good to go.  The sanity check
>on the 9-scoring - I'll think about that in the morning and adjust the
>rationale
>as necessary and make that more water tight.  Also - I like the idea of
>coloring a box - when a particular technology has the sole highscore
>in that category.
>
>Thanks, DW.
>=======================================================
>Message text written by "Monica J. Martin"
> >David,
>May I suggest you at least note there are other messaging formats out
>there that are not assessed that may be relevant to particular industry
>segments such as RosettaNet and one other if you can think of it and not
>leave RN as the only one.
>
><