RE: CPP & CPA Followup

[Joseph Baran <joebaran@extol.com>]

The set of CPP & CPA samples posted at:

http://www.ebxml.org/project_teams/poc/tokyo/

all have the contents of their PartyName (and RolePlayer) elements 
expressed in the format:

companynameNN

where:

companyname ==  PartyName as in the suggested table (as quoted below)

and

NN == one or more of 21,22,31,32, depending on track and role

In addition, the actual xml filenames and the CPAName elements follow a 
similar pattern, e.g.:

in a CPP:
<CPAName>Extol22 CPP</CPAName>
in a CPA:
<CPAName>Netfish21 and Extol22 CPA</CPAName>

Now, the suggested table drops the "NN" part. This is probably fine if each 
PartyName plays only one role, but several are playing more than one role. 
(e.g., see Netfish in the table below).

Questions:

1.	Are there any potential problems in dropping the "NN" convention? (I 
think there are....)
2.	If not, should all of the posted CPPs and CPAs be renamed & edited 
accordingly?
3.	If it is decided that the "NN" suffix (or any equivalent differentiator) 
is actually necessary in PartyName, should there also be a unique domain 
name for each PartyName?


Joe Baran


-----Original Message-----
From:	Mark Hale [SMTP:hale@ajubasolutions.com]
Sent:	Friday, October 27, 2000 2:04 PM
To:	ebXML-poc
Subject:	CPP & CPA Followup

<<snip>>

3.  Here is the first cut at the PartyName/Track/Role/DUNS/DomainName 
table:

Cisco/TPA/Client/2110000000000/cisco.ebxml.com
Extol/Retail/Seller/3210000000000/extol.ebxml.com
Fujitsu/Retail/Buyer/4210000000000/fujitsu.ebxml.com
IBM/Automotive/Supplier/5320000000000/ibm.ebxml.com
IBM/TPA/Buyer/5110000000000/ibm.ebxml.com
Interwoven/TPA/Buyer/1110000000000/interwoven.ebxml.com
IPnet/Automotive/Buyer/6210000000000/ipnet.ebxml.com
Netfish/Retail/Buyer/7210000000000/netfish.ebxml.com
Netfish/Retail/Supplier/7220000000000/netfish.ebxml.com
Netfish/Retail/Hub/7230000000000/netfish.ebxml.com
Netfish/Automotive/Supplier/7320000000000/netfish.ebxml.com
Savvion/Retail/Seller/8220000000000/savvion.ebxml.com
SterlingCommerce/TPA/Registry/9118220000000/sterlingcommerce.ebxml.com
SUN/TPA/Registry/1511000000000/sun.ebxml.com
TIE/Retail/Buyer/1021000000000/tie.ebxml.com
TIE/Retail/Seller/1022000000000/tie.ebxml.com
Viquity/Retail/Hub/1123000000000/viquity.ebxml.com
webMethods/Retail/Buyer/1221000000000/webmethods.ebxml.com
XMLGlobal/TPA/Registry/1311000000000/xmlg.ebxml.com
XMLSolutions/TPA/Registry/1311000000000/xmls.ebxml.com

<<snip>>