RE: Registry Headers

[Mark Hale <hale@ajubasolutions.com>]

I agree with using QueryManager for the Service Interface.  I think that we
should uniquely bind the Actions.  Can we make the Action equal to the Root
Node of the Payload (e.g. GetRootClassificationNodesRequest and
GetRootClassificationNodesResponse, etc.) since there is some sematic
meaning behind their naming?

	Thanks,

	Mark



> -----Original Message-----
> From: JP Morgenthal [mailto:jp.morgenthal@xmls.com]
> Sent: Monday, October 30, 2000 1:14 PM
> To: 'Nicholas Kassem'; ebxml-Poc (E-mail)
> Subject: RE: Registry Headers
>
>
> I like, but can we decide on this today because this impacts the
> handling of
> these messages.
>
> Thanks.
>
> JP
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Nicholas Kassem [mailto:Nick.Kassem@eng.sun.com]
> Sent: Monday, October 30, 2000 4:07 PM
> To: hale@ajubasolutions.com
> Cc: ebXML poc
> Subject: RE: Registry Headers
>
>
> Mark,
>
> Please see my comments.
>
> Nick
>
> At 03:48 PM 10/28/2000 -0700, Mark Hale wrote:
> >With respect to the ebXML Headers required to interact with
> RegRep, we need
> >to finalize on the header info.  I think that the suggestion that I made
> >earlier went on a long-winded tangent.  Please permit to back up
> and see if
> >we can reach consensus.
> >
> >Step 1:  The header looks the following where and we are trying to reach
> >consensus on --A-- and --B--
> >
> >         <ebXMLHeader>
> >           <Header>
> >             <TPAInfo>
> >               <TPAId context = "POC">
> >                 CPA/CPAInfo/CPAName
> >               </TPAId>
> >               <ConversationId context = "POC
> >                 uid@requester-domain [from request message]
> >               </ConversationId>
> >               <ServiceInterface>     --A--    </ServiceInterface>
> >               <Action>  --B--      </Action>
> >             </TPAInfo>
> >           </Header>
> >           ...
> >         </ebXMLHeader>
> >
> >Step 2:  I propose the values of A & B should be:
> >
> >  --A-- == Object Query Manager
> >   Note:  This is only one of several service interfaces
> >  --B-- == GetRootClassificationNodesRequest
> >   Note:  This is only one of several actions within the interface
> >
> >Step 3:  I suggested the locations of A & B in the cpp-cpa DTD in the
> e-mail
> >sent earlier.  Please do not use the locations in the header.  Rather I
> >thought I would tell you exactly where you can find the values
> of A & B in
> >the DTD:
> >
> >--A-- ==
> CPA/BusinessProtocol/BusinessInterface/ServiceInterface?InterfaceId
>
> Not sure this needs to be a distinguished name - why not simply:
> QueryManager
>
> >--B-- ==
> >CPA/BusinessProtocol/BusinessInterface/ServiceInterface/ActionMen
> u/Action/R
> e
> >quest/RequestMessage
>
> Same as above - why not for example, simply use :
> getRootClassificationNodes
>
> Nick