RE: latest Version

[Stefano POGLIANI <stefano.pogliani@sun.com>]

Nikola,

	I agree that the MS enforces parts of the TPA, BUT under the control of the Business Service Interface and not by itself. I mean, the BSI uses the MS to manage things that are specific to the MS and that would not make sense to be managed elsewhere: but this does not mean that the MS enforces the TPA. 
The TPA as a whole is enforced, IMO, by the BSI (policy manager) using the services of the MS.

I do not want to make a whole point of this. My real point is that the MS by itself does not know how to enforce the TPA.

/Stefano

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Nikola Stojanovic [mailto:nhomest1@twcny.rr.com]
> Sent: Monday, October 16, 2000 11:42 PM
> To: ebXML Architecture
> Subject: Re: latest Version
> 
> 
> <Stefano>
> <Line 1070 in Figure 17>
> TPA enforcement IS NOT in the Messaging Layer but in the Business Service
> Interface.
> <\Line 1070 in Figure 17>
> <\Stefano>
> 
> "enforcement" is certainly a strong word here and I can understand your
> comment. However, I hope we agree that there is a part of TPA (I might not
> be using the latest terminology here), which is MS specific 
> (timeout,  time
> between retries, ... and who knows what else). I would say that there is a
> piece of TPA that is enforced by MS. The question is what it is. So far we
> didn't have, AFAIK, objection to this from TR&P group and the same section
> was posted to them recently. Also, there has been a very lively, on-going
> discussion in TP group related to this issue and I would like to see more
> feedback on this from them as well. To sum it up, I wouldn't take it out
> yet.
> 
> Regards,
> Nikola
> 
>